Roth Vs Traditional After Tax Value
Calculator

Inputs

Traditional account after-tax value
37,452.294809

Results

Traditional account after-tax value
37,452.294809
Roth account after-tax value
35,625.353599
Roth advantage
-1,826.94121

Retirement planning results

Traditional account after-tax value37,452.294809
Roth account after-tax value35,625.353599
Roth advantage-1,826.94121

formula-map diagram

Traditional account after-tax value
37,452.294809
Roth account after-tax value
35,625.353599
Roth advantage
-1,826.94121

Retirement planning relationship

Formula

Traditional = C×(1+i)^n×(1-t_retire) ; Roth = C×(1-t_now)×(1+i)^n

= 37452.294809897

Note

This is not financial advice. It is a simplified model: it applies the displayed standard formula to the figures you entered, assumes a single constant rate for every year, and ignores taxes, fees, sequence-of-returns risk, health costs, longevity risk and any country's specific pension, benefit or minimum-distribution rules. Real returns can be negative and real retirements rarely follow a smooth curve. Check the assumptions and consult a licensed adviser before acting on any figure.

Example: with the default inputs, calculator.retirement.traditional_after_tax_value is 37452.29480989725.

More in Retirement planning

See all →

Frequently asked questions

How does this compare Roth and traditional accounts?+

It applies the same growth to the same pretax amount in both. Traditional = contribution × (1 + i)^n × (1 − retirement tax rate); Roth = contribution × (1 − current tax rate) × (1 + i)^n.

What does the Roth advantage figure mean?+

It is the Roth after-tax value minus the traditional after-tax value. A positive number favors Roth under your inputs; a negative number favors traditional.

When does Roth come out ahead in this calculation?+

Because both sides grow by the same factor, the comparison reduces to the two tax rates. Roth is higher when your current marginal rate is lower than your retirement marginal rate, and traditional is higher in the reverse case.

What tax rates should I enter?+

Enter your own marginal rates, today and expected at retirement. The calculator does not look up brackets, so the result is only as good as those guesses.

What does this calculation leave out?+

It uses one lump contribution and a constant return, with no ongoing contributions, fees, state taxes, contribution limits or withdrawal penalties. It is an estimate, not tax or financial advice.